The Expert’s Paradox: I Was a Cognitive Scientist Who Knew Everything About Meditation, Except How to Do It. The Answer Wasn’t in a Lab—It Was in a Sketchbook.

Part I: The Agony of “Trying”: My Failure as a Mindfulness Expert

Introduction: The Fraud on the Cushion

There is a unique and exquisitely painful irony in being an expert in a field you personally fail at.

For nearly a decade, this was my life.

By day, I was a cognitive scientist specializing in contemplative neuroscience.

I could stand in a lecture hall and speak with authority about the neurological correlates of mindfulness, pointing to fMRI scans that showed the thickened prefrontal cortexes of long-term meditators.¹

I could cite meta-analyses demonstrating statistically significant reductions in stress, anxiety, and rumination.²

I could deconstruct the core principles of present-moment awareness, explaining how it involves observing thoughts and feelings without judgment, using the breath as an anchor to the here and now.³

I had the vocabulary, the data, and the credentials.

What I didn’t have was the experience.

By night, or more accurately, in the quiet five or ten minutes I would carve out each morning, I was a fraud.

I would sit on the cushion, a symbol of my professional life, and feel like an imposter.

The simple, elegant instructions I gave to others became instruments of my own mental torture.

“Focus on your breath,” the script would go.⁶

My analytical mind would immediately begin to commentate: “Okay, breathing in.

One.

Now breathing O.T. Two.

Is this a deep enough breath? Should it be from the belly? I think I’m doing this wrong.” The instruction to “gently bring your attention back when it wanders” ⁵ became a relentless cycle of failure and self-recrimination.

My mind would wander—that was a given, a documented phenomenon affecting nearly 47% of our waking hours ⁷—but my return was never gentle.

It was a jolt of frustration.

“There I go again.

I can’t even do this for ten seconds.

I’m terrible at this.”

I was caught in the most common of traps, the one that ensnares countless beginners: I was constantly asking, “Am I doing this right?”.⁸

The more I knew about the profound benefits—the improved emotional regulation, the enhanced cognitive function, the decreased job burnout ¹⁰—the higher the stakes felt, and the more acute my sense of failure became.

I was the cartographer who could draw a perfect map of a country he had never managed to visit.

The Humiliating Session: A Key Failure Story

The nadir of this professional-personal dissonance arrived on a gray Tuesday afternoon.

As a young academic, eager to translate my research into practical application, I had agreed to lead a “mindfulness for focus” workshop for a cohort of beleaguered graduate students.

They were the perfect subjects: overworked, overwhelmed, and desperate for any tool that might quiet the relentless pressure of their studies.

I felt confident.

I had the slides, the studies, and the standard script.

I began the session as I was taught, as every app and pop-psychology article advises.

“Find a comfortable, upright posture,” I said, my voice echoing slightly in the sterile seminar room.³

“Close your eyes, or soften your gaze.

Now, bring your attention to the sensation of your breath…”

What followed was not the gentle descent into calm I had described, but a five-minute eternity of escalating psychic noise.

From my own cushion, I could sense the room’s agitation.

A pen dropped.

Someone coughed.

A chair creaked.

Through my own tightly shut eyelids, I could feel the fidgeting, the sighs of frustration.

My own mind, far from being a serene anchor, was a tempest.

They’re not getting it.

I’m not explaining it well.

My voice sounds strained.

Is that person checking their phone? I bet they are.

This is a disaster.

When the timer finally chimed, the collective sigh of relief was audible.

The debrief was a polite bloodbath.

“I just couldn’t stop thinking,” one student admitted, echoing the most common struggle of all.⁹

“It actually made me feel

more anxious,” said another, a phenomenon that, while less discussed, is a real risk when meditation is misapplied.¹³

“I felt sleepy, then I felt restless,” confessed a third, ticking off the classic “hindrances” of sloth and agitation.¹⁵

One student even mentioned feeling dizzy, a common but unnerving side effect often related to posture or breathing patterns.¹³

I had no good answers.

I could only offer the same hollow platitudes: “That’s normal.

Just notice the thoughts without judgment.

The goal isn’t to have a blank mind.” But I knew, with a certainty that chilled me, that these words were useless.

I had led them directly into the same cognitive trap I was caught in.

That humiliating session became a turning point.

It forced me to confront a devastating question: if the standard model of mindfulness fails the very people it’s supposed to help, what is fundamentally wrong with the model?

Deconstructing the “McMindfulness” Trap: Why Standard Advice Fails

My professional training compelled me to analyze this failure not as a personal shortcoming, but as a systemic problem.

I began to deconstruct the very way mindfulness is taught and understood in modern Western culture, and I realized the issue was far deeper than a few poorly phrased instructions.

The first problem is one of cultural translation.

As mindfulness journeyed from its ancient roots in Eastern contemplative traditions, particularly Buddhism, to the secular, fast-paced West, it underwent a significant transformation.¹⁷

Spearheaded by pioneers like Jon Kabat-Zinn, who brilliantly integrated the practice with Western science to create the Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) program, mindfulness was stripped of much of its ethical and philosophical context.¹⁷

It was repackaged and marketed as a therapeutic tool, a technique for self-improvement aimed at reducing stress, enhancing productivity, and managing anxiety.¹⁹

This created what critics have called “McMindfulness”—a commodified, bite-sized version of a profound practice, sold as a quick fix for the anxieties of modern life.²⁰

This reframing from a way of being to a tool for achieving a goal is the genesis of the trap.

It establishes a goal-oriented expectation from the outset.

You are not meditating to explore the nature of your mind; you are meditating to become calm or get focused.

This immediately activates the part of the brain responsible for striving and problem-solving.

Compounding this is the inherent vagueness of the instructions.

Phrases like “just be” or “let it go” are not procedural; they are poetic descriptions of an outcome.²¹

For an analytical mind, which thrives on clear, step-by-step processes, this is maddeningly opaque.

It’s like telling a novice carpenter to “just be a table.” This leads directly to the most pervasive misconception about meditation: that the goal is to “empty the mind” or “stop thinking”.⁹

Since the mind’s nature is to produce thoughts, this is an impossible task, one that guarantees a feeling of failure.

This sets up a disastrous causal chain.

The Western, commercialized framing creates a goal-oriented expectation (e.g., “I must become calm”).

The standard instructions provide no clear, actionable method to achieve this goal.

The analytical mind, faced with a goal and no method, defaults to its primary strategy: effortful problem-solving.

It treats the “wandering mind” as a defect to be corrected and “calm” as a state to be engineered through force of will.

But this very act of striving, judging, and controlling is a form of intense mental activity.

It is the cognitive equivalent of flooring the accelerator to try and stop a car.

This effortful “trying” directly generates the most common struggles: restlessness, increased anxiety, frustration, and a profound sense of personal failure.⁹

The problem wasn’t the students.

The problem wasn’t me.

The problem was the framework itself.

We weren’t “bad at meditating”; we were being given a broken tool and then blamed when it didn’t work.

The solution couldn’t be to try harder within this flawed paradigm.

I needed a completely new one.

Part II: The Epiphany: Shifting from Thinking to Seeing

The Unlikely Teacher: A Dog-Eared Copy of a Drawing Manual

The breakthrough didn’t come from a neuroscience journal or a contemplative retreat.

It came, as epiphanies often do, from a completely unexpected direction.²³

After the debacle with the graduate students, I quietly shelved my personal practice.

I couldn’t bear the feeling of hypocrisy.

I focused on my research, on the objective data, and tried to ignore the disconnect in my own life.

Months later, seeking a mental escape, I found myself in a dusty used bookstore.

On a whim, I picked up a dog-eared copy of Betty Edwards’s 1979 classic, Drawing on the Right Side of the Brain.

I had no artistic aspirations; I simply wanted a hobby, something tangible and completely removed from the abstract world of cognitive science.

I had no idea that in learning to see the world as an artist, I would finally learn how to inhabit it as a meditator.

The Paradigm Shift: From L-Mode to R-Mode, From Symbol to Perception

The core premise of Edwards’s book was a revelation.

She explained that we have two fundamental ways of processing the world, loosely associated with the brain’s left and right hemispheres.²⁵

• L-Mode (The Symbolist): This is our analytical, verbal, logical mind. It thinks in names, categories, and symbols. When the L-Mode looks at a person’s face, it doesn’t just see shapes and light; it thinks “eye,” “nose,” “mouth.” When a beginner tries to draw from this mode, they don’t draw what they see; they draw the generic symbol of an eye they’ve held in their mind since childhood—an oval with a circle inside. The L-Mode is fast, efficient, and essential for navigating the world, but it is a terrible artist because it substitutes reality with a simplified map.
• R-Mode (The Perceiver): This is our non-verbal, spatial, intuitive mind. It doesn’t deal in symbols or names. It simply perceives. It sees pure data: the curve of a line, the angle of a shadow, the shape of the empty space between two objects. To learn to draw realistically, Edwards argued, one must learn techniques that deliberately quiet the dominant L-Mode and allow the R-Mode to take over.

As I read this, a jolt went through me.

I realized with stunning clarity that this was the key to my entire struggle.

I had been trying to meditate with my L-Mode.

I was chasing the symbol of “calm.” I was labeling my breath, judging my thoughts, and analyzing my performance.

Standard meditation advice, with its verbal, goal-oriented instructions, is almost perfectly designed to activate the L-Mode.

It is an L-Mode instruction for what is fundamentally an R-Mode task.

The solution, then, wasn’t to try harder to “let go” or “not judge.” That was just more L-Mode chatter.

The solution was to find a new set of instructions, a new method, that functioned like Edwards’s drawing exercises—tricks designed to bypass the analytical “Symbolist” and awaken the silent “Perceiver.” The goal shifted from thinking about the present to directly sensing the present.

This insight allowed me to deconstruct the old, failed cues and replace them with new, perception-based alternatives.

Table 1: Deconstructing Meditation Cues: From Cognitive Trap to Perceptual Shift

Standard Cue	The Cognitive Trap (Why It Fails)	The Perceptual Alternative (The Drawing Analogy)	The Cognitive Shift (How It Works)
“Clear your mind.”	Sets an impossible goal. The mind’s job is to think. Trying to stop it creates more mental noise and a sense of failure.9	“Notice the negative space.” (Focus on the silence between thoughts, just as an artist draws the space around an object.)	Shifts attention from an impossible task (thought suppression) to an achievable one (perceiving absence). It bypasses the content of thoughts entirely.
“Focus on your breath.”	L-Mode immediately labels it (“I’m breathing in, now I’m breathing out”) and then judges it (“Am I doing it right? Is it deep enough?”).	“Perceive the raw sensations of the breath.” (Feel the coolness at the nostrils, the stretch of the belly, as pure sensory data, like tracing a line with your eyes.)	Moves from conceptualizing the breath to directly experiencing it as a physical event.3 It short-circuits the inner commentator and grounds awareness in the body.
“Gently bring your attention back.”	Becomes a cycle of self-criticism. “I wandered again. I’m so bad at this.” The “gentle” part is lost to L-Mode’s judgment.15	“You’ve just noticed a new object in your field of vision.” (Like an artist noticing a new detail in their subject, you simply acknowledge the thought as another shape in the composition.)	Reframes “distraction” as “discovery.” It removes the judgment of failure and replaces it with neutral observation, fostering equanimity.4
“Let go of your thoughts.”	L-Mode interprets this as an active struggle—”I must push this thought away”—which is a form of resistance that strengthens the thought.	“Observe the thought’s texture and trajectory.” (Watch it arise, persist, and fade like a cloud moving across the sky, without getting on the cloud.)	Changes the relationship from wrestling with a thought to witnessing it. It cultivates non-attachment by creating distance, not by force.26

Part III: The Perceptual Model of Mindfulness: A Four-Pillar Framework

Armed with this new paradigm, I developed a new approach to mindfulness, one based not on abstract commands but on concrete perceptual skills.

I call it the Perceptual Model, and it rests on four pillars, each one directly inspired by a core artistic skill.

Pillar 1: Perceiving Contours — The Art of the Body Scan

One of the first exercises in Edwards’s book is “pure contour drawing.” The artist looks at an object—say, their own hand—and draws its outline without ever looking down at the paper.

The goal is to make the act of seeing and the act of drawing a single, unified process.

This forces the L-Mode to quiet down because it can’t verify the drawing against its internal symbol of a “hand.” You are forced to trust your raw perception of the object’s edge.

This exercise maps perfectly onto the Body Scan Meditation.⁵

In the Perceptual Model, the goal of the body scan is not to “relax” the body (an L-Mode goal that invites judgment and striving).

The goal is to perform a pure contour drawing with your attention.

You move your awareness slowly through the body, from the toes to the head, with the sole intention of perceiving the raw sensory “contours” of each part.

You are not looking for anything in particular.

You are simply noticing what is there: pressure, warmth, coolness, tingling, vibration, itchiness, numbness, or the complete absence of sensation.

When you approach the body scan this way, your relationship with physical sensations changes dramatically.

A knot of tension in the shoulder is no longer a “problem” to be fixed.

It is simply a dense, warm, and perhaps pulsating area of sensory data.

Chronic pain in the lower back is no longer a monolithic enemy; it is a complex landscape of sharp, dull, hot, and radiating sensations.

By shifting from judging the sensation to perceiving its contours with high fidelity, you can be present with even intense discomfort without being overwhelmed by it.⁹

You are learning to see the physical reality of your body, rather than just living in the L-Mode’s story about it.

Pillar 2: Seeing Negative Space — The Power of the Gaps

A profound leap in artistic skill occurs when a student stops trying to draw the object itself and learns to draw the “negative space” around it.

Instead of drawing the chair, you draw the shape of the empty space between the chair legs.

The L-Mode has no symbol for this “non-thing,” so it falls silent, allowing the R-Mode to perceive the shapes and relationships accurately.

In meditation, our thoughts are the “objects.” They are the chairs that fill the room of our mind.

The standard advice is to deal with these objects directly—to watch them, to let them go.

But for a busy mind, this can feel like being in a room crowded with shouting people.

The Perceptual Model offers a different strategy, one inspired by drawing negative space: stop looking at the thoughts and start looking for the silence.

Instead of fighting the “river of thoughts” that threatens to sweep you away ²⁸, you sit on the riverbank.

But you don’t just watch the water (the thoughts) go by.

You actively listen for the gaps.

You attune your awareness to the brief moments of quiet

between the thoughts.

This is a crucial shift.

The instruction to “let thoughts pass” is passive; it leaves you at the mercy of your mind’s current.

The instruction to “listen for the silence” is an active, engaging perceptual task.

It gives the attention a specific, non-conceptual target.

This simple reframe transforms the entire practice.

It turns the frustrating battle against thinking into a game of perceptual hide-and-seek.

You are giving the chattering L-Mode a job it can’t do (it can’t “think” about silence) and engaging the R-Mode in a task it excels at (perceiving absence).

It gives the proverbial “monkey mind” ²⁹ something fascinating to look for, and in the looking, it naturally becomes quieter.

This is a direct, practical solution to the universal complaint, “I can’t stop thinking.” You don’t have to.

You just have to learn to see the space around the thoughts.

Pillar 3: Understanding Relationships — Observing Thoughts as Objects in a Field

A mature artist does not just render individual objects accurately.

They understand composition.

They see the relationship between objects—how they are placed in a field, how their relative sizes create depth, how light and shadow connect them into a coherent whole.

This skill maps to the meditative principle of Observation Without Attachment, or what is sometimes called “de-centering”.⁴

The core realization here is that your thoughts, emotions, and sensations are not

you.

They are transient objects arising and passing away within the vast, open field of your awareness.

You are not the anger; you are the space in which anger appears.

You are not the worry; you are the awareness that perceives the worry.

The drawing analogy provides the master framework for this shift in perspective.

You are learning to see the “composition” of your own mind.

Within this framework, the classic metaphors for mindfulness become incredibly useful tools—different “lenses” for viewing this composition:

• Thoughts as Passengers on a Bus ²⁶: This metaphor is perfect for observing the relationship between your intention and your mental chatter. You are the driver, with a chosen destination (your values, your goals). The thoughts are noisy, often critical passengers shouting contradictory directions. Your job is not to argue with them or eject them from the bus, which would require stopping. Your job is to acknowledge their presence, keep your hands on the wheel, and continue driving toward your destination.
• Thoughts as Clouds in the Sky ²⁹: This metaphor excels at highlighting the nature of awareness itself. You are the vast, stable, boundless sky. Thoughts, emotions, and moods are like clouds—some light and fluffy, others dark and stormy. They pass
  through the sky, but they are not the sky. The sky is unchanged by the weather that moves within it. This helps cultivate a stable sense of self that is not defined by fleeting mental states.
• Thoughts as Leaves on a Stream ²⁷: This metaphor is a powerful tool for observing the transient, impersonal nature of thoughts. You sit on the bank of a stream and watch as leaves float by. Each leaf is a thought or feeling. You simply note its presence—”Ah, a planning thought,” “There’s a memory,” “That’s a flicker of sadness”—and watch it float on downstream, without needing to jump into the water after it.

The key to all these metaphors is the compositional shift in identity.

You move from being fused with the content of your mind to identifying with the vast, silent container that holds it all.

You become the artist observing the canvas, not just one of the brushstrokes.

Pillar 4: The Final Drawing — Integrating Perception into Daily Life

The ultimate goal of learning to draw is not just to create better drawings; it’s to learn to see the world with greater richness and clarity.

An artist who has mastered these perceptual skills walks through the world differently.

They notice the subtle play of light on a face, the elegant composition of a city street, the surprising beauty of negative space in a tangle of branches.

Similarly, the payoff of the Perceptual Model of meditation is not just a calmer ten minutes on the cushion.

It’s the integration of these perceptual skills into the fabric of daily life.⁷

This is where the practice moves “off the mat and into real life situations”.²⁴

You start to notice the “negative space” in a tense meeting at work—the pause before someone speaks—which gives you a crucial moment to respond thoughtfully instead of reacting defensively.

You feel a surge of anger and, instead of being consumed by it, you experience it as a “contour” of heat in your chest and tightness in your jaw, allowing you to observe it without being driven by it.

You catch yourself spiraling into anxious thoughts and recognize them as “passengers on the bus,” allowing you to return your focus to the road ahead.

You become more present, more flexible, and more connected to the world as it actually Is.³²

I know this because I put it to the test.

A year after my first, humiliating workshop, I was invited to speak to another group of graduate students.

This time, I threw out the old script.

I began by telling them about my own failures and then introduced them to the drawing analogy.

I didn’t tell them to “clear their minds.” I led them through a “contour drawing” of the sensations in their hands.

I didn’t tell them to “let go of thoughts.” I invited them to become detectives, listening for the “negative space” of silence.

The atmosphere was entirely different.

Instead of restless agitation, there was a quiet, engaged curiosity.

In the debrief, the comments were not of failure, but of insight.

“I’ve never felt my own hands like that before,” one said.

Another remarked, “Focusing on the silence was like a game.

It was the first time my mind wasn’t fighting itself.” It was a personal and professional breakthrough, the successful “drawing” that proved the value of the perceptual framework.²⁴

Part IV: The Science of Sight: Validating the Perceptual Model

While this model was born from a personal epiphany and an artistic analogy, it is deeply grounded in the very neuroscience I had studied for years.

The shift from L-Mode to R-Mode is not just a clever metaphor; it reflects real, measurable changes in brain function and structure that explain the wide-ranging, scientifically-validated benefits of the practice.

Grounding the Analogy in Neuroscience

The “Symbolist” L-Mode corresponds closely with a major brain network that neuroscientists call the Default Mode Network (DMN).

The DMN is our brain’s autopilot, our “me-story” generator.

It’s most active when we are not focused on a specific task—when our minds are wandering, ruminating about the past, worrying about the future, and engaging in self-referential thinking.²

An overactive DMN is strongly linked to conditions like anxiety and depression.³⁰

The Perceptual Model is, in essence, a systematic training program for disengaging the DMN.

By directing attention to raw sensory data (Pillar 1) or the perception of silence (Pillar 2), you are activating the

Task-Positive Network (TPN), which is involved in focused, present-moment attention.

This act of noticing that the mind has wandered and redirecting it is a workout for the Prefrontal Cortex (PFC), the brain’s executive center responsible for impulse control, decision-making, and emotional regulation.¹

Every time you feel the “tug of the leash” as the puppy of your attention wanders ³⁴ and you guide it back to a perceptual anchor, you are performing a mental “Rep.” Over time, this literally strengthens and thickens the PFC, which helps protect against age-related cognitive decline.¹

Remarkably, positive changes in the brain have been documented after as little as eight weeks of regular practice.¹

Furthermore, this model directly explains how mindfulness improves emotional regulation.

When you experience an emotion like anger not as a story (“He wronged me, this is unfair!”) but as a set of physical contours (heat in the chest, clenched jaw), you decouple the raw affective sensation from the L-Mode’s narrative about it.

This process of “de-centering” allows you to stand on the riverbank and watch the emotion pass by, rather than being swept away by it.³⁰

This is why fMRI studies show that meditators have less neural reactivity when exposed to emotionally upsetting stimuli; they have trained their brains to respond more skillfully.²

The evidence is clear: this practice leads to tangible, positive outcomes across a wide spectrum of human health and well-being.

Table 2: A Summary of Scientifically-Validated Benefits of Mindfulness

Benefit Area	Key Scientific Finding / Statistic	Primary Source(s)
Stress Reduction	Mindfulness-based therapies are effective in altering cognitive and affective processes underlying clinical issues. An 8-week MBSR program significantly reduced anxiety, depression, and somatic distress.	2
Anxiety & Depression Management	Mindfulness helps people “de-center” from negative thoughts, watching them like “leaves on a stream.” It is shown to reduce rumination and has been effective in preventing depression relapse.	2
Improved Focus & Working Memory	In a high-stress military group, mindfulness practice increased working memory capacity, whereas it decreased in a non-meditating control group. Experienced meditators show significantly better performance on all measures of attention.	2
Brain Health & Plasticity	Long-term meditators have a thicker prefrontal cortex (PFC), protecting against age-related cortical decline. Positive brain changes are documented after just 8 weeks of practice.	1
Pain Management	Meditation can reduce the perception of pain by increasing activity in brain centers that control pain. A study of 3,500 people found meditation reduced complaints of chronic or intermittent pain.	1
Improved Sleep	Mindfulness-based interventions have been found to improve sleep quality, enhance sleep duration, and reduce sleep disturbances.	11
Addiction & Habit Control	Meditation develops mental discipline and willpower, helping to break dependencies by increasing awareness of triggers and improving self-control over cravings and impulses.	30

Conclusion: Becoming the Artist of Your Own Awareness

My journey into the heart of mindfulness began with the hubris of an expert and led me through the humbling reality of a failed practitioner.

The answer I was looking for wasn’t in the brain scans or the academic papers.

It was in the simple, profound wisdom of learning to see.

The core message of the Perceptual Model is this: Stop trying to meditate.

Start learning to see.

Meditation is not a mystical state to be achieved, but a practical, perceptual skill to be cultivated, just like drawing.

The goal is not to have a blank mind, but a mind you can finally see with clarity, compassion, and a touch of artistic detachment.

It is about becoming the curious observer, the skilled composer, the patient artist of your own awareness.

A Call to Practice: Your First Sketch

If you have struggled with meditation, if you have felt like a failure on the cushion, I invite you to put down the old, broken tools and pick up a new sketchbook.

Here is your first, simple assignment.

• Step 1: Get Your Materials. Find a quiet place where you can sit comfortably for a few minutes. A chair is perfectly fine; just try to keep your back straight but not stiff.⁶ Set a timer for just five minutes. The key is frequency, not duration. A short, daily practice is far more effective than a long, sporadic one.²²
• Step 2: Your First Contour Drawing. For the first two minutes, close your eyes and bring your attention to your breath. But do not label it or try to control it. Your only task is to perform a “contour drawing” of the physical sensation. Feel the precise place where the air feels cool as it enters your nostrils. Trace the subtle expansion of your belly or chest. Treat it as pure sensory data, nothing more.
• Step 3: Look for the Negative Space. For the next two minutes, let your focus on the breath soften. Shift your attention to the entire field of your awareness. Your new task is to listen. Not for thoughts, but for the silence between the thoughts. Be a detective looking for gaps. You may only find a half-second of quiet, or you may find more. Just notice it.
• Step 4: Sign Your Work. When the timer goes off, take one final moment. Notice any sounds in the room. Notice how your body feels. Notice your thoughts and emotions, whatever they may be. Do not judge the session. You have completed your first sketch. The goal was not to create a masterpiece. The goal was simply to put pencil to paper.

Do it again tomorrow.

This is how an artist begins.

This is how you begin.

Works cited

1. Mindfulness Meditation: Health Benefits and How to Start – UCLA Health, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.uclahealth.org/news/article/mindfulness-meditation-health-benefits-and-how-to-start
2. What are the benefits of mindfulness?, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.apa.org/monitor/2012/07-08/ce-corner
3. Mindfulness Meditation: Finding Calm and Acceptance in the …, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.caregiver.va.gov/docs/Mindfulness-Meditation-Finding-Calm-and-Acceptance-in-the-Present-Moment-rev.pdf
4. The 10 Principles Of Meditation – Paradoxical Vista, accessed August 11, 2025, https://paradoxicalvista.org/the-10-principles-of-meditation/
5. Getting Started with Mindfulness, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.mindful.org/meditation/mindfulness-getting-started/
6. Learn How to Meditate: A Mindful Guide to Transform Your Life, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.mindful.org/how-to-meditate/
7. How Present-Moment Awareness Can Make Life More Meaningful – Mindful.org, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.mindful.org/how-present-moment-awareness-can-make-life-more-meaningful/
8. Best guide for beginners? : r/Meditation – Reddit, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Meditation/comments/38w53b/best_guide_for_beginners/
9. Trouble Meditating? Here’s Advice For 17 Common Issues …, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.headspace.com/meditation-101/trouble-meditating
10. Mindfulness exercises – Mayo Clinic, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/consumer-health/in-depth/mindfulness-exercises/art-20046356
11. Wellness Weekly: the power of mindfulness meditation | Marquette Today, accessed August 11, 2025, https://today.marquette.edu/2024/02/wellness-weekly-the-power-of-mindfulness-meditation/
12. How to meditate for beginners – Mental wellbeing tips – Every Mind Matters – NHS, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.nhs.uk/every-mind-matters/mental-wellbeing-tips/how-to-meditate-for-beginners/
13. 9 Most Common Struggles With Meditation, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.thedailymeditation.com/8-most-common-struggles-with-meditation
14. Difficulties that can arise during practice – Melbourne School of Psychological Sciences, accessed August 11, 2025, https://psychologicalsciences.unimelb.edu.au/CSC/contemplative-resource-hub/difficulties
15. Common Issues and Difficulties with Meditation – Loyola University Maryland, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.loyola.edu/department/counseling-center/services/students/relaxation/mindfulness-meditations/common-issues.html
16. Overcome These Five Common Obstacles to Meditation – Mindful.org, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.mindful.org/overcome-these-five-common-obstacles-to-meditation/
17. The History and Origins of Mindfulness – PositivePsychology.com, accessed August 11, 2025, https://positivepsychology.com/history-of-mindfulness/
18. History of Mindfulness | Human Resources and Organizational Excellence – Clark University, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.clarku.edu/human-resources/2021/11/22/history-of-mindfulness/
19. How Mindfulness Has Changed On The Journey From Eastern To Western Civilizations, accessed August 11, 2025, https://ripplefloat.com/how-mindfulness-has-changed-on-the-journey-from-eastern-to-western-civilizations/
20. A Critique on Mindfulness in the United States – Austin Family Counseling, accessed August 11, 2025, https://austinfamilycounseling.com/a-critique-on-mindfulness-in-the-united-states/
21. Mindfulness Meditation Doesn’t Work. Here’s Why., accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.beingpeacefully.com/dharma-blog/mindfulness-meditation-not-working
22. Why do so many of us struggle with meditation? – Patient.info, accessed August 11, 2025, https://patient.info/news-and-features/why-do-i-keep-failing-at-meditation
23. Meditation as a tool to support a carer in extremis (a personal experiment), accessed August 11, 2025, https://forum.alzheimers.org.uk/threads/meditation-as-a-tool-to-support-a-carer-in-extremis-a-personal-experiment.55109/
24. I had an unbelievable breakthrough, months of practice paying off! : r/Meditation – Reddit, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Meditation/comments/81zmp5/i_had_an_unbelievable_breakthrough_months_of/
25. Why learning how to draw is a near-perfect analogy for mindfulness …, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Meditation/comments/ap71nu/why_learning_how_to_draw_is_a_nearperfect_analogy/
26. Metaphors | Get.gg – Getselfhelp.co.uk, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.getselfhelp.co.uk/metaphors/
27. Mindfulness of Thoughts | Penn Psychiatry | Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.med.upenn.edu/psychiatry/mindfulness_of_thoughts.html
28. Meditation Analogy: The River Of Thoughts – The Overthinker – WordPress.com, accessed August 11, 2025, https://georgecoghill.wordpress.com/2021/01/09/meditation-analogy-the-river-of-thoughts/
29. Does anyone have any good analogies for thoughts and the observer? : r/Meditation, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Meditation/comments/15glk6o/does_anyone_have_any_good_analogies_for_thoughts/
30. Mindfulness for Your Health | NIH News in Health, accessed August 11, 2025, https://newsinhealth.nih.gov/2021/06/mindfulness-your-health
31. A Powerful Metaphor for Defusing from Negative Thoughts – New York Behavioral Health, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.newyorkbehavioralhealth.com/powerful-metaphor-for-defusing-negative-thoughts/
32. Mastering the Present Moment: From ‘Doing’ to ‘Being’ Mode – YouTube, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4qUw5x0rWEU
33. “I’ve got 99 problems but healing my nervous system solved like 90 …, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Mindfulness/comments/145nhrv/ive_got_99_problems_but_healing_my_nervous_system/
34. Mindfulness, Metaphors, and More – The Florida Bar, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.floridabar.org/the-florida-bar-news/mindfulness-metaphors-and-more/
35. 12 science-based benefits of meditation – Hunimed, accessed August 11, 2025, https://www.hunimed.eu/news/12-science-based-benefits-of-meditation/